"Long Baroque"
This reed style can be used for a historical bassoon with a baroque bore design such as the following : Eichentopf, Bizey, or Rottenburgh. The longer lengths of this design does not usually perform well with a Prudent or classical bassoon bore.
I. Montage
Cane Selection and Preparation
1. Choose tube cane; Try to find softer cane. One will have better
results with soft cane than hard cane since with the tapered gouge the
vibrating portion of the blade will be made from a more stiffer layer of
the cane.
Fröhlich: a) the diameter of the tube should be about
a pouce
(1 inch or about 25 mm)
b) thickness of the pith needs to be as thin as possible
2. Saw tube cane to length of 150 mm
Choose the portion of the tube that is flat and round
3. Split tube into 3 pieces, cut out the portion of the cane (4 or 5
mm) with the branch growth.
4. Soak cane for about 24 hours (change water if necessary)
Fröhlich: soak cane for about 4-5 hours before gouging
Gouging
5. Use flat gouge: cut down edges to remove excess cane quickly
6. Gouge with #5 gouge: gouge entire length down to a thickness of 1.60 mm
7. Cut notches: a) Cut center notch
b) Cut end of scrape notch 15 mm from tip
c) Cut first wire notch
34 mm from stock
8. Gouge with #6 and Woodward disks until the following gouge thickness:
Note the eccentric or "crescent" gouge. Therefore, the gouge
is tapered both from center to sides and lengthwise.
Gouge thickness
Shaping
9. Cut center line on easel and fold
10. One can shape by hand or by using a shaper. Shape using a
knife then sandpaper to the following width dimensions:
A Rieger B2 or B3 works well.
Tip 18 mm
First wire 12 mm
Back 11 mm
Forming Blank
11. Score and cut through back
12. Beveling back 10 to 15 mm from stock
13. Install wires; at first use .7 mm thick wire, later one can change
to .8 thick wire.
First wire: 38 mm from the stock
Second wire: ca. 7 mm behind first wire
14. Wrap with string and insert mandrel. Apply cork grease to
mandrel.
15. Re-align blades if necessary
16. Install 3rd wire about 4 mm from stock.
17. Place on mandrel and let dry for 24 hours
18. When reed is thoroughly dry, re-tighten wires, dip in melted beeswax and install wrapping.
II. Reed Finishing
1. Cut tip; start with a total reed length of about 72-73 mm
2. Using a knife or file, form the U-shaped profile about 15 mm from
tip.
Use what I call an en biseau cut.
3. Play reed frequently using the reed tests below; continue to remove
cane until
reed performs and responds as desired.
4. Clip back tip if reed is flat or high register does not respond.
Dimension Summary
Total length 72-73 mm
Tip to 1st wire 35 mm
1st wire to 2nd wire 10 mm
2nd wire to the stock 28 mm
1st wire to the stock 38
Reed Tests
1. When played with a middle range air/embouchure balance, reed and
bocal
alone should produce a C (a = 415 hz).
2. Play octaves; the three Gís are a good test since these notes are
in the low,
middle and high range of the bassoon.
3. Play Bb2 and Bb3 using the forked simple fingering.
The octave should be relatively in-tune, although this octave
is normally a bit too wide.
Materials
Cane, in tube form
Sandpaper
Bed for gouging
Easel (1" dowel works well)
Scraper
Nail rasp
Brass wire, .7 and .8 mm
File
Shaper
Gouge
Woodward scraping disks #32, #36
Razor blades or utility knife for scoring and beveling
Knife for scraping blades
Mandrel
String for forming
String for turks head
(Plaque or tongue)
Beeswax
Address
Hand Gouges; Gaignard-Millon, Machines et Outillage
24, Rue Jules-Vallès
75011 Paris France
Fax 33.01.43.71.51.35
Scraping Disks: Bill Woodward
12 Nottingham Drive
Greensburg, PA 15601 USA
Fax 1.724.834.4451
woodward@westol.com
Tools; Georg Rieger GmbH
Postfach 1446
D-76554 Gaggenau Germany
Fax 49 072 25 76828
Tony Allcock
217 Curzon Street
Long Eaton
NG10 4FG U.K.
44.0115.972.6377
General Principles
A historical performance system is a reed with a bassoon attached.
A modern performance system is a bassoon with a reed attached.
Reliance on Cane Quality (density)
En Biseau This refers to a scrape that is such that the spine is made with the gouge not the profile. It also refers to a type of scrape that is chiseled down into the cane.
Historical Manner of Playing the Bassoon
A historical reed is just one component of a complete manner of playing
a historical instrument. It should be noted that this system makes
higher demands on the player, particularly in the area of Air/Embouchure
Balance.
Historical instrument
Historical reed
Correct Air/Embouchure balance
Reed slanted, see Ozi 1803, p. 1, p. 2; Cugnier, Essai page
Placement of lips on reed, see Cugnier in Essai page 332
Proper amount of lip pressure on reed
Proper throat opening
Historical fingering
A historical manner of playing supports:
Flexibility of pitch
Ease of playing ornaments
Proper tone quality (see Cugnier, Mordant).
Technical facility, thanks to simple basic fingerings
"Must Know" Historical Bassoon Reed-Making Bibliography
Fröhlich, Joseph, "Fagott-Schule," in Vollständige Theoretisch-Musiklehre...,
1810 and 1829.
Ozi, Étienne, Nouvelle Méthode de Basson, Paris: 1803,
Minkoff Reprint, 1974.
Smith, David Hogan, Reed Design for Early Woodwinds,
1992: Indiana University Press. ISBN 0-253-20727-4
Waterhouse, William, The New Grove, London: 1980 sv Bassoon.
White, Paul, The Early Bassoon Reed in Relation to the Development
of the
Bassoon from 1636, University of Oxford Dissertation, 1993.
Criteria for Historical Bassoon Reeds
(not order of importance)
1. Play at the proper pitch level for a particular instrument, usually
415 hz.
2. Be flexible enough in pitch to do the following:
a. to play trills using simple fingerings.
b. to play forked fingerings in-tune
c. to play in a "well" temperament or a less severe mean-tone
temperament
d. produce in-tune octave
3. Be able to play in the second octave using simple fingerings.
For example, being able to play Eb3 with 1-3 fingering, and E3
with just 1
4. Play at various dynamic levels.
5. Play with proper tone quality (see Cugnier, Mordant).
6. Play with a range of Bb to A3, with desired attack
[7. Play with no hole on the bocal or at least with a very small one.
By very small I mean less than .5 mm. This one is in parentheses
because I am not sure it is possible or really necessary.]
Goals or Challenges of Historical Reed-Making
1. Being able to play with desired tone quality and dynamic level are
always difficult, even with modern reeds.
Usually the darker the sound of a reed is, the more difficult is the
response.
Historical reeds tend to be on the bright or buzzy side, I think that
the desired sound before the 20th century was much brighter than what we
are used to today.
2. Being able to make a reed that will both play softly and comfortably
in the high register.
3. Making a reed that is flexible enough to play the simple trills
and at the same time being able to use the simple fingerings in the tenor
range.
4. Making a reed that will do all the above criteria that is not extremely
taxing on the embouchure.
The area behind the scrape needs to be thick to give the reed
strength, as the heart does for a modern reed.
5. The problem with spliting.
Since historical reeds are made from the dense area near the
fiber band, the reeds tend to be brittle and will crack easily.
This problem seems to be made worse by using a plaque.
This could be why neither Ozi or Fröhlich speaks about
using a plaque.
What Makes a "Historical Bassoon Reed"
1. Use of contrapente, where most of the work in making a reed is done
on gouge, very little profiling and scraping.
This I think is most important because, but the sound of a reed made
from fibers closer to the "fiber band" is different than if it is made
of the less dense material.
2. The profile should be one that the ratio of center of palette (scrape)
to the sides is about even. In other words, there should not
be a pronounced spine (arête) or heart.
3. Shape or form of reed; tip width, width at first wire, shape of
blade.
In the primary sources and on the original reeds that have come down
to us, one will find that the shapes and dimensions vary a great deal.
In fact, one could say that there really wasnít one model or
design that
was universal. However, two very basic shape/dimension
designs seem to be seen most often: 1) the "tulip" design discussed
by Ozi and
2) the "straight side" designdiscussed by Fröhlich and
others.
4. Dimensions and wire placement; this includes total length, length
of scrape.
Characteristics which are not important to the design
of a Historical Bassoon Reed;
-if one uses Duco cement
-if one uses a third wire (at end of tube) or not
-if one uses string or a Turks Head on tube
-if one can see bark near tip
Similar characteristics of original Bassoon reeds
Most all of the original reeds that I have personally seen are similar
in the following ways:
1. Relatively flat at the first wire.
2. The scrape is what I call en biseau and what I mean by that
is when the scraped part of the blade is cut at a very deep angle as soon
as the scrape starts. In other words, if the scrape does not go down
into the cane gradually as in a modern reed, but is deep into the cane
very quickly. This en biseau means that there is very little
heart or spine.
3. The gouge is thinner at the tip, which also has implications on
the heart.
This lack of a real heart (the relation of the center of the reed to
the sides or a thicker center spine of modern Heckel system reeds) is a
very important characteristic of an historical reed. It gives the
reed its sound and playing characteristics. This characteristic
makes the "feel" of the instrument totally different than a reed based
on a modern model with a spine. If there is an area of the reed that
gives it strength, it is the area behind the scrape. This area between
the end of the scrape and the first wire becomes quite thick quickly.
Why many baroque bassoon players give up on historical reeds and
prefer more a modern reed design:
1. The sound on historical reeds is of course different, brighter,
more like a French system bassoon sound.
2. I think that in general to make a historical reed do all the requirements
that I listed it needs to be harder than a modern model reed. This
is of course takes some getting used to since the piano response is not
as predictable and endurance can be a problem.
3. When one plays historical reeds, one has to use a more "engaged
embouchure" and by that I mean one has to use a more flexible embouchure.
Each note must be made by the Air/Embouchure balance. Or...
You are consistently changing your embouchure pressure on the reed to make
a note play in-tune or play in a particular register. However, this
flexibility one of the advantages of the historical reed, it makes the
trills and ornaments easier to perform. For example, one can play
a Bb or B above the staff with the same fingering.
4. At first, if one does not take the time to learn how to play on
these reeds, some things become difficult because the system is "less forgiving."
For example, making a very soft entrance on a low note in an orchestra.
So in effect, if one plays on an historical reed, one has to re-learn to
play the bassoon, especially in the area of "breath-leading," and many
players are not in position to do this.