Special Topics: Eyewitness Identification
Spring 2009

Dr. Otto H. MacLin
Associate Professor

Department of Psychology
University of Northern Iowa


Office: BAK 355
Office Hours
Phone: (319) 273-2373
Fax: (319) 273-6188
E-mail: Otto.MacLin@uni.edu
 

 
 

 
Location = Baker 315
Time = 3:30 to 4:45 Tuesday & Thursday

Course description and goals

This course will cover research on eyewitness identification.

The goals of the course are to:

Introduce students to the area of eyewitness identification and its implications for understanding how memory for individuals works for within the legal system. Introduce system and estimator variables. Obtain familiarity with the following research topics and methodology to understand how eyewitness identification is experimentally studied and how the results are used in the legal system. Develop a research proposal on the topic of eyewitness identification.

Assignments

Readings/Commentary Papers -- 30%

You will be reading from various journals and sections of books.

The class meets twice a week we will cover a new topic each week. You will be required to write a 300 word commentary paper for each class period over the reading materials – due the day the class first meets about a topic (this will help give you incentive to read the materials before class).  These commentary papers should reflect to some extent the following:  a) your personal reaction to the topic area (did it personally effect  you in some way, did it ring true with your personal experiences); b) your critique of the a specific article reading (a reflection on one of the readings in terms of what you particularly liked and disliked about it from a theoretical and/or methodological view); c) a take home picture that you obtain from having read and reflected upon all the readings for that day; or d) a research idea that you that comes from the readings. 

Class involvement: Participation & Presentation -- 30%

    A assessment of your class involvement will also be made.   This goes beyond demonstrating that you have read the material.  It encompasses your attendance and attention during class and your responsiveness and thoughts about comments made by other students in class. It will include class presentations.

Research proposal -- 20%

At the end of the semester, on the first day of exam week, you will be required to turn in a research proposal.  This research proposal should consist of a) an abstract of the paper; b) a brief introduction to the topic area of interest in the introduction and a development of your hypothesis, c) a method section illustrating how you would conduct your study, d) a result section with “dry lab” data illustrating the way that you would analyze your data and the findings that would hope to obtain that would support your hypotheses, e) a short discussion section that summarizes what you see as would the most important implications of the findings and what else you might like to do assuming you would get (or not get) the findings your propose.

Topic summary and bibliography --20%

More information about the summary and bibliography will be provided later in the course.

Your grade will be based upon the distribution as noted above.  Cheating in any form will result in flunking from the class.  Please see the college's statement on academic integrity.

Eyewitness topics:

Policy
Weapons focus
Exposure time
Delay
Stress/Arousal (Kelli Case)
Cross-race identification (Caralyn Wilkerson)
Description accuracy / Verbal overshadowing (Sean Babinat)
Interviewing (Matt Sullivan)
Lineup construction (Steve Berg)
Lineup administration (Heather Caspers)
Confidence accuracy / Malleability
Post-event information (Alex Esquivel)
Juror knowledge Amanda Dobson)
Pre-trial publicity
Ecological validity
Unconscious transference (Dwight Peterson)
Show-ups
Composites
Mug shot books (Elizabeth Mendez)
Safeguards
Expectations
Structural bias / Mockwitness evaluation
Children/Elderly eyewitnesses (Staci Devera)
Context
Wrongful convictions (Ian Anserson)
 

Academic Ethics Policies: The University policy on academic ethics as it relates to plagiarism and cheating is clearly spelled out on pages 62-63 (section 3.01) of the current UNI catalog and is also printed on the bottom of the syllabus. It is YOUR responsibility to be familiar with this policy and abide by it.  Note especially that ignorance of this policy is NOT an acceptable defense - so if you have any questions about the policy contact me or your advisor.  Should there be any indication of plagiarism or cheating, I will follow this policy and I will impose those consequences spelled out in this policy with NO exceptions.  Anyone violating this policy will receive an “F” for the course and will be reported to the Provost's office.

Instructional Accommodations:
Students requesting instructional accommodations due to disabilities as described under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 should arrange for such accommodation by contacting the Office of Disability Services, 213 Student Services Center (ph. 273-2676).

Classroom Etiquette: (or things that shouldn’t need to be said but apparently do) Please keep in mind that this is an educational experience and that your conduct has an impact on others.  You are not required to attend classes; if you do attend, however, certain behaviors are unacceptable and discourteous to the instructor and your classmates.  Among them are sleeping, reading, and talking to classmates during lecture.  The class will begin promptly at the scheduled time and you are expected to be in your seat and quite at that time.  Books and notebooks are to be put away when the lecture is over - not 5 minutes before.  Use of headphones, pagers, palm pilots (PDAs), cell phones, laptop computers, or any other electronic equipment is NOT permitted during class.  Failure on your part to observe these guidelines will result in my asking you to leave the class for the remainder of the period.