"Writing is 1 percent inspiration and 99 percent elimination."
Louise Brooks
The best way to learn how to write well is to learn how to write concisely. There is no room for pedantic verbosity when writing abstracts. This is your opportunity to challenge yourself to write well and write economically.
Your task is to collaborate with your Abstract Partner to write an abstract for an assigned article.
| Criteria | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|
Content |
|||
Topic |
Paper topic is well-described in a single sentence | Paper topic description is general or takes more than one sentence. | Paper topic description is vague or takes more than one sentence. |
Purpose |
The purpose, thesis or organizing construct is described. The article's scope is included. | The purpose, thesis or organizing construct is described. OR The article's scope is included | The purpose, thesis or organizing construct is described but vague OR The article's scope is included but vague. |
Sources |
All of the sources that were used are described to provide the reader with a feeling of the information's authenticity. | Some of the sources that were used are described to provide the reader with a feeling of the information's authenticity. | Few of the sources that were used are described to provide the reader with a feeling of the information's authenticity. |
Conclusions |
Conclusions drawn in the article are succinctly but completely identified. | Conclusions drawn in the article are succinctly but incompletely identified. | Conclusions drawn in the article included, but are neither succinct nor incomplete. |
Writing Style |
Scholarly writing style is used. Concise and positively written. Uses appropriate vocabulary and phrases. Sentences are | Areas to Improve: |
|
Grammar/Spelling |
1 or less error in spelling, grammar or punctuation | 2 errors in spelling, grammar or punctuation | |
Length |
Abstract is 120 words or less | ||
Title |
Title is academic in format and succinct. | ||
Subtotal |
|||
Total |
|||
Submission: Dr. Z will evaluate your abstract and review your partnership work (using the Revision History) in Google Docs, but you will be expected to post your final abstracts to the appropriate posting in the course's Discussion section. You are asked to post it there so that your colleagues can enjoy and admire your work.
January 30, 2009