|
|
pts |
|
pts |
|
pts
|
|
| Title/Purpose
|
|
|
2 |
Title
is identified AND Purpose of paper is described. |
1 |
Title
is identified OR Purpose of paper is described. |
| Introduction |
3 |
- Problem being
investigated is fully described.
- Importance
of the problem is fully described.
- Scope (areas
of interest) of the review is identified.
|
2 |
One of the following
is not fully described:
- Problem being
investigated.
- Importance
of the problem.
Scope of the review.
- Scope of
the review
|
1 |
Two of the following
are not fully described:
- Problem being
investigated.
- Importance
of the problem.
Scope of the review.
- Scope of
the review
|
| Research
Questions |
3 |
3 or
more research questions are listed which correspond with the scope
of the review. |
2 |
2 research
questions are listed which correspond with the scope of the review. |
1 |
1
research question is listed which correspond with the scope of the
review. |
| Methodology |
3 |
- Methods used
to identify sources. (DBs used etc.)
- Descriptors
identified
|
2 |
One of the following
is described:
|
|
|
|
Analysis
and Discussion
|
3 |
- Evidence
is organized by topic areas described in the scope.
- Evidence
is cited in relation to the references at the end of the outline.
- Sequence
within the subtopics makes sense.
|
2 |
2 of
the followings are true:
- Evidence
is organized by topic areas described in the scope.
- Evidence
is cited in relation to the references at the end of the outline.
- Sequence
within the subtopics makes sense.
|
1 |
1
of the following is true:
- Evidence
is organized by topic areas described in the scope.
- Evidence
is cited in relation to the references at the end of the outline.
- Sequence
within the subtopics makes sense.
|
| Conclusions
& Recommendations |
3 |
- Preliminary
conclusions are made.
- Preliminary
recommendations for research or application are made.
|
2 |
1 of the following
is true:
- Preliminary
conclusions are made.
- Preliminary
recommendations for research or application are made.
|
1 |
|
|
References
|
3 |
6 or
more references listed |
2 |
4 -
5 References listed |
1 |
2
- 3 References listed |